242 SATISFACTION SURVEYS
189 EXTERNAL EVALUATIONS
33
PILOT TESTS
The evaluation of the project has been carried out through the monitoring and evaluation of all activities and phases, as well as through external evaluators who have evaluated the quality of the project. When a phase of the project ends, we use indicators that allow us to evaluate the phase as a whole.
During the planning phase we established a TOTAL QUALITY SYSTEM through which we implemented the PRINCE2 METHOD and generated evaluation mechanisms.
Through this method, an Evaluation/Optimization/Profitability (EO) process was carried out during all stages and phases based on:
*EO1. EVALUATION PLANNING through the creation of the EVALUATION AND QUALITY PLAN in the planning phase and the implementation of the Total Quality System and the PRINCE2 Method from the preparation phase.
*EO2. INFORMATION COLLECTION of all evaluation mechanisms at the end of each stage, phase and main activity. The data collection methods were not limited to satisfaction surveys, but we undertook a process based on 4 ways:
– Internal evaluations of results by the entities’ experts
– External evaluations by internationally renowned experts
– Pilot tests, using the results with the beneficiaries themselves.
– Collection of statistical data
*EO3. ANALYSIS OF THE INFORMATION obtained through the analysis of indicators, survey results, external evaluations and pilot tests through the software GRAPHPAD PRISM 8 SOFTWARE (GRAPHPAD SOFTWARE, USA) with which we carried out a statistical study.
*EO4. OPTIMIZATION and ensure economic and social profitability through the creation of results that have managed to generate a significant impact.
PILOT TEST
We have carried out 33 pilot tests that have allowed us to evaluate the main results. More than 120 secondary school teachers and 50 students have participated in these pilot tests.
These pilot tests have been carried out in entities that are experts in low vision and in numerous educational centres.
• ALBA, Asociación para la ayuda a personas con albinismo
• Aniridia Europe
• Aniridia Norge
• Aniridia Italiana
• DANSK FORENING FOR ALBINISME
• NOAH Albinismus Selbsthilfegruppe e.V.
• ALBINIT
• OOGVERENIGING
• Norsk Forening for Albinisme Norsk Forening for Albinisme
• Albinism derneği
• Albinism Fellowship
• Simplemente Amigos – Fundación Nacional de Albinismo
• Corporación de albinos Chile
• Asociación Española de Aniridia
• Aniridi Sverige
• Aniridia Network
• Aniridia Finland
• Aniridi Danmark
• Aniridia Bulgaria
• Greta du Velay
• Greta de Monistrol-sur-Loire
• Greta Nord Allier
• Greta Dore-Allier
• Greta Auvergne
• Greta Monts du Cantals
• Greta Boubonnais Combraille
• Greta d’Yssingeaux
• Lycée Polyvalent Emmanuel Chabrier
• Lycée Professionnel Auguste Aymard
• Lycée Professionnel Jean Monnet
• Lycée Simone Weil
• Lycée Charles et Adrien Dupuy
• Lycée LaFayette
QUALITY AND PROGRESS EVALUATION
OUTPUTS EVALUATION
IMPACT EVALUATION
EXTERNAL EVALUATION
To validate the quality of the project and the results generated in it, a large number (189) of international evaluators experts in the field of innovative education have been contacted (several of them being members of the evaluation committees of the most relevant international congresses on educational innovation). Below, we list the set of experts who have evaluated the project:
Complete name | Affiliation | Country |
Adam Frost | University of Manchester | UNITED KINGDOM |
Adriana Agnes Repellin-Moreno | Universidad Panamericana | MEXICO |
Aileen Cotter | Cork Institute of Technology | IRELAND |
Akihiro Maeda | Ryukoku University | JAPAN |
Alexander Mikroyannidis | The Open University | UNITED KINGDOM |
Alia Ammar | Drexel University | UNITED STATES |
Aline Grunewald Nichele | Federal Institute of Education, Science and Technology of Rio Grande do Sul | BRAZIL |
Amtiaz Fattum | The Arab Academic College for Education – Haifa | ISRAEL |
Ana Lucas | Universidade Europeia / Laureate International Universities | PORTUGAL |
Ana Paula Lopes | Polytechnic Institute of Oporto | PORTUGAL |
Anamarija Štefić | Josip Juraj Strossmayer University of Osijek | CROATIA |
Andrew Youde | The University of Huddersfield | UNITED KINGDOM |
Anemona Peres | Frontex | POLAND |
Anna Romagnuolo | University of Tuscia | ITALY |
Anne Marie Martino | New York City Department of Education | UNITED STATES |
Asako Ohno | Osaka Sangyo University | JAPAN |
Asta Daunoriene | Kaunas University of Technology | LITHUANIA |
Bob Barrett | American Public University | UNITED STATES |
Boza Tasic | Ryerson University | CANADA |
Bozena Mannova | Czech Technical University in Prague | CZECH REPUBLIC |
Breno Deffanti | Graded – The American School of São Paulo | BRAZIL |
Catherine O’Donnell | Ulster University | UNITED KINGDOM |
Chang-Tik Chan | Monash University Malaysia | MALAYSIA |
Chiew Hong Ng | National Institute of Education | SINGAPORE |
Christopher Evans | Cardiff University | UNITED KINGDOM |
Craig Loewen | University of Lethbridge | CANADA |
Craig Walker | Oklahoma State Department of Education | UNITED STATES |
Cynthia Rosas Magallanes | Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social (IMSS) | MEXICO |
D. Joan Domingo Peña | Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya | SPAIN |
D. Andrés Camacho García | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Antonio Molina Marco | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Carlos Galindo Pastor | Universitat Jaume I | SPAIN |
D. David Carabantes Alarcón | Universidad Complutense de Madrid | SPAIN |
D. David de Andrés Martínez | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Emilio Vivancos Rubio | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Ester Giménez Carbó | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Faraón Llorens Largo | Universitat d´Alacant | SPAIN |
D. Francisco Javier Camacho Torregrosa | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Francisco Javier Hoyuelos Álvaro | Universidad de Burgos | SPAIN |
D. Germán Moltó Martínez | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Ignacio Bosch Roig | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Jaume Fabregat Fillet | Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya | SPAIN |
D. Javier Paricio Royo | Universidad de Zaragoza | SPAIN |
D. Jesús Alba Fernández | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Joaquín Alejandro Guerra Achem | Tecnológico de Monterrey | SPAIN |
D. José Álvarez Teruel | Universitat d´Alacant | SPAIN |
D. José Luis Giménez López | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. José Luis Martín Núñez | Universidad Politécnica de Madrid | SPAIN |
D. José Vicente Salcedo Romero de Ávila | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Juan Antonio Monsoriu Serra | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Juan Carlos Morales Sánchez | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Juan Luis Bravo Ramos | Universidad Politécnica de Madrid | SPAIN |
D. Martín Llamas Nistal | Universidad de Vigo | SPAIN |
D. Miguel Ángel Fortea Bagán | Universitat Jaume I | SPAIN |
D. Miguel Ferrando Bataller | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Miguel Leiva Brondo | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Miguel Rebollo Pedruelo | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Miguel Sanhueza Olave | Universidad Tecnológica Metropolitana | SPAIN |
D. Rafael Balart Gimeno | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
D. Rafael Oliver Cuello | Universitat de Vic-UCC | SPAIN |
D. Raúl Santiago Campión | Universidad de la Rioja | SPAIN |
D. Roberto Carballedo Morillo | Universidad de Deusto | SPAIN |
D. Sixto Romero Sánchez | Universidad de Huelva | SPAIN |
D. Vicente Martínez García | Universitat Jaume I | SPAIN |
D. Víctor Yepes Piqueras | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª Ana Mª Delgado García | Universitat Oberta de Catalunya | SPAIN |
Dª Idoia Begoña Fernández Fernández | Universidad del País Vasco UPV/EHU | SPAIN |
Dª Mari Paz Prendes Espinosa | Universidad de Murcia | SPAIN |
Dª Mónica Feixas Condom | Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona | SPAIN |
Dª Roser Grau Vidal | Universitat de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Amparo Graciani García | Universidad de Sevilla | SPAIN |
Dª. Amparo Ribes Greus | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Ana María Arnal Pons | Universitat Jaume I | SPAIN |
Dª. Ana Rosa Abadía Valle | Universidad de Zaragoza | SPAIN |
Dª. Ángeles Calduch Losa | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Carla Sentieri Omarrementeria | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Concepción Bueno García | Universidad de Zaragoza | SPAIN |
Dª. Eloína Coll Aliaga | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Esther Sanabria Codesal | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Eva Emmanuel Martínez | Universidad del País Vasco | SPAIN |
Dª. Francesca Romero Forteza | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Irene Epifanio López | Universitat Jaume I | SPAIN |
Dª. José Ignacio Herranz Herruzo | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Josefa Mula Bru | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Llucia Monreal Mengual | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Mª Asunción Martínez Mayoral | Universidad Miguel Hernández | SPAIN |
Dª. Mª Asunción Pérez Pascual | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Mª Gracia López Patiño | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Mª José Pérez Peñalver | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Mª Pilar Bonet Espinosa | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Mercedes López Santiago | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Nagore Ipiña Larrañaga | Universidad de Mondragón | SPAIN |
Dª. Pilar Aurora Cáceres González | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Raquel Conchell Diranzo | Universitat de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Rosabel Roig Villa | Universidad de Alicante | SPAIN |
Dª. Sara Ibáñez Asensio | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Susana Martínez Naharro | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Teresa Pages Costas | Universidad de Barcelona | SPAIN |
Dª. Teresa Pardo Vicente | Universitat Politècnica de València | SPAIN |
Dª. Vanessa González Fernández | Universidad de Sevilla | SPAIN |
Daniel Abrahams | University of Arkansas – Fayetteville | UNITED STATES |
Darren Falconer | The University of Western Australia | AUSTRALIA |
David Jennings | University College Dublin | IRELAND |
Denis Liakin | Concordia University | CANADA |
Desiree Cranfield | Swansea University | UNITED KINGDOM |
Elena Savova | University of Library Studies and Information Technologies | BULGARIA |
Elmaziye Özgür | Eastern Mediterranean University | CYPRUS |
Emmanuel Glakpe | Howard University | UNITED STATES |
Ewa Bogacz-Wojtanowska | Jagiellonian University | POLAND |
Farhad Eftekhari | TechClass Ltd. | FINLAND |
Fausto Brevi | Politecnico di Milano | ITALY |
Fedor Duzhin | Nanyang Technological University | SINGAPORE |
Fernando Enrique Ortiz Rodriguez | Universidad Autonoma de Tamaulipas | MEXICO |
Filomena Soares | Polytechnic of Porto | PORTUGAL |
Frank Brosow | University of Education Ludwigsburg | GERMANY |
Gaby Probst | Haute École de Gestion | SWITZERLAND |
Guenter Tusch | Grand Valley State University | UNITED STATES |
Hanna Haydar | Brooklyn College – City University of New York | UNITED STATES |
Hanna-Riitta Kymäläinen | University of Helsinki | FINLAND |
Helen Reddy | University of Nottingham | UNITED KINGDOM |
Helmut Wöllik | Carinthia University of Applied Sciences | AUSTRIA |
Hiroyuki Obari | Aoyama Gakuin University | JAPAN |
Ineta Helmane | University of Latvia | LATVIA |
Iolie Nicolaidou | Cyprus University of Technology | CYPRUS |
James Mackay | Otago Polytechnic | NEW ZEALAND |
Jana Bérešová | University of Trnava | SLOVAKIA |
Jane Davies | University of Nottingham | MALAYSIA |
Jaroslaw Kujawski | University of Gdansk | POLAND |
Jennifer Robinson | University of Arizona Global Campus | UNITED STATES |
Joanna Richardson | City, University of London | UNITED KINGDOM |
João Monteiro | ISPGAYA – Instituto Superior Politécnico Gaya | PORTUGAL |
John Craft | Appalachian State University | UNITED STATES |
Joseph Agbenyega | Emirates College for Advanced Education | UNITED ARAB EMIRATES |
Kari Krell | MacEwan University | CANADA |
Kathleen O’Sullivan | University College Cork | IRELAND |
Katia Karadjova | Georgia Southern University | UNITED STATES |
Kay Gallagher | Zayed University | UNITED ARAB EMIRATES |
Laila Nordstrand Berg | Western Norway University of Applied Sciences | NORWAY |
Laura Mason | Swansea University | UNITED KINGDOM |
Laura Zizka | Ecole Hôtelière de Lausanne / HES-SO University of Applied Sciences and Arts Western Switzerland | SWITZERLAND |
Leonor Silva de Mattos | University of Hertfordshire | UNITED KINGDOM |
Luis Roseiro | Instituto Superior de Engenharia de Coimbra | PORTUGAL |
Luke Raeside | Technological University Dublin | IRELAND |
Manuel Gericota | Polytechnic of Porto | PORTUGAL |
Manuela Milani | Humanitas University | ITALY |
Maria Luisa Spreafico | Università degli Studi di Milano | ITALY |
Maria Rudneva | RUDN University (Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia) | RUSSIAN FEDERATION |
Maria Susy Rogers | The University of South Wales | UNITED KINGDOM |
Martha Leal-Gonzalez | Institute of Innovation and Technology Transfer of Nuevo Leon | MEXICO |
Martina Bode | University of Illinois at Chicago | UNITED STATES |
Mathilde Celume | Beyond Education | FRANCE |
Matome Mashiapata | University of South Africa | SOUTH AFRICA |
Mayaugust Finkenberg | Stevenson University | UNITED STATES |
Michelle Flood | Royal College of Surgeons | IRELAND |
Mike Hillis | California Lutheran University | UNITED STATES |
Monika Jakubiak | Maria Curie-Sklodowska University | POLAND |
Nathalie Wessseling | Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences | NETHERLANDS |
Oli Howson | The Open University | UNITED KINGDOM |
Orlando Belo | Universidade do Minho | PORTUGAL |
Pamela Brett MacLean | University of Alberta | CANADA |
Paul Hunter | IMD, International Institute for Management Development | SWITZERLAND |
Peter Gabor | University of Calgary | CANADA |
Peter Haber | Salzburg University of Applied Sciences | AUSTRIA |
Pia Palotie | Eezy Tyollisyyspalvelut | FINLAND |
Polona Gradišek | University of Ljubljana | SLOVENIA |
Rachel Morgan-Guthrie | University of Wolverhampton | UNITED KINGDOM |
Rebecca Allen | Mount St. Joseph University | UNITED STATES |
Remigijus Bubnys | Vilnius University | LITHUANIA |
Rosa Cendros Araujo | Western University | CANADA |
Sandra Gomes | IPAM | PORTUGAL |
Sean Lancastle | University of Bristol | UNITED KINGDOM |
Sinéad McCotter | University of York | UNITED KINGDOM |
Siobhan O’Sullivan | Khalifa University in Medical Education | UNITED ARAB EMIRATES |
Staffan Elgelid | Nazareth College | UNITED STATES |
Suzy Connor | Kyushu University | JAPAN |
Sylvia Dempsey | Cork Institute of Technology | IRELAND |
Taija Chaya Votkin | Aalto University | FINLAND |
Taketoshi Yokemura | Shibaura Institute of Technology | JAPAN |
Tammy Ladwig | University of Wisconsin Fox Valley | UNITED STATES |
Teemu Patala | Context Learning Finland Oy | FINLAND |
Teresa Cardoso | Universidade Aberta, LE@D | PORTUGAL |
Thomas Lavery | The Royal Academy of Engineering | UNITED KINGDOM |
Thomas Rachfall | Hochschule Merseburg | GERMANY |
Tunde Szecsi | Florida Gulf Coast University | UNITED STATES |
Victor Fester | University of Waikato | NEW ZEALAND |
Victoria Brennan | Liverpool John Moores University | UNITED KINGDOM |
Victoria Kompanets | Lappeenranta University of Technology | FINLAND |
Wayne Bailey | The University of Huddersfield | UNITED KINGDOM |
Wendy Gorton | Educational consultant | UNITED STATES |